AnandTech Home IT Portal Home Increase Font Size Decrease Font Size Change Page Size
AMD's 3rd generation Opteron versus Intel's 45nm Xeon: a closer look
AMD's 3rd generation Opteron versus Intel's 45nm Xeon: a closer look
Date: November 27th, 2007
Topic: IT Computing
Manufacturer: Various
Author: Johan De Gelas
Buy the HP 457557-B21 2347 HE Opteron
Blank
 PC Connection $300.51
 OnSale.com $305.99
 MacMall $305.99
 
 

Software Rendering: zVisuel (32-bit Windows)

This benchmark is the zVisuel Kribi 3D test, which is exclusive to AnandTech.com and which simulates the assembly of a mechanical watch. The complete model is very detailed with around 300,000 polygons and a lot of texture, bump, and reflection maps. We render more than 1000 frames and report the average FPS (frames per second). All this is rendered on the "Kribi 3D" engine, an ultra-powerful real-time software rendering 3D engine. That all this happens at reasonable speeds is a result of the fact that the newest AMD and Intel architectures contain four cores and can perform up to eight 32-bit FP operations per clock cycle and per core. The people of zVisuel told us that - in reality - the current Core architecture can sustain six FP operations in well-optimized loops. Profiling for Barcelona architecture is not yet complete, so we did our best with CodeAnalyst 2.74 for Windows. We only profiled the non-AA benchmark so far.

ZVisuel Kribi3D Profiling
Profile Total
Average IPC (on Opteron 2350) 1
Instruction mix
Floating Point 31%
SSE 35%
Branches 6%
L1 datacache ratio 0.63
L1 Instruction ratio 0.22
Performance indicators on Opteron 2350
Branch misprediction 8%
L1 datacache miss 1%
L1 Instruction cache miss 1%
L2 cache miss 0%

This is a very different engine than the scanline-rendering engine of 3ds Max. SSE instructions play a very dominant role, and the zVisuel Kribi 3D benchmark gives us a view on how the different CPUs perform on well-optimized SSE applications. While the application seems to run almost perfectly from the L2 cache, this seems to be a result of well-tuned, predictable access to the memory. We noticed that hardware prefetching and the new Seaburg chips help this benchmark a lot:

Zvisuel Intel Platform Performance Comparison
CPU HW Prefetch on HW Prefetch disabled Difference
Dual Xeon E5365 3.0 (Blackford) 99.9 87.7 14%
Dual Xeon E5365 3.0 (Seaburg) 110 104.2 6%
Dual Xeon E5472 3.0 (Seaburg) 124.8 110 13%

Let us see all the results.


zVisuel
Watch Assembly (no AA)


zVisuel
Watch Assembly (high quality AA)

Although we haven't done a detailed analysis, we can assume that the "Super Shuffle Engine" and "Radix-16" divider that Intel has implemented in the Xeon 5472 is paying off here. AMD Opteron 2360 SE at 2.5GHz can overtake the best Xeon at 65nm, but the new Xeon has a tangible lead. A silver lining to the cloud hanging over AMD is that the Opteron 23xx series scale perfectly with clock speeds: compare the 2GHz with the 2.5GHz results. Still, Intel has the advantage when it comes to SSE processing.

The results with AA show that the memory subsystem of the Xeon 53xx is a major bottleneck, but the new Seaburg chipset has made this bottleneck a bit smaller. The result is a crushing victory for the latest Intel architecture. Enough FP testing, let us see what Barcelona can do when running typical integer server workloads.

64-bit Linux Java Performance: SPECjbb2005   Next Page

 
  Index

Tools Share
Find lowest prices Find the lowest prices
Digg   del.icio.us   E-mail  
Print This Article Print this article  

43 Comments - Last by befair, 357 days ago
Username:
Password:
GIF by jojo4u, 724 days ago
Yuck, ugly GIF on the first page. Please use PNG because 256 colors are not enough for screenshots ;)

Reply
RE: GIF by SonicIce, 724 days ago
I think the color depth was decreased alot more than 8 bit. That image only has 33 unique colors in it. Something went wrong with the dithering maybe? 256 is usually more than enough.

Reply
RE: GIF by Justin Case, 721 days ago
Who cares? The only part that suffers is the gradient at the top, all the relevant information is there, and this file is about half the size of what a PNG would be.

Reply
RE: GIF by jkostans, 724 days ago
Didn't even notice.

Reply
RE: GIF by aeternitas, 708 days ago
Then why are you here? Details is what technology is about!

I for one have a pet peeve with tech sites that use the wrong formats in their stories. Slightly damages credibility. Not to say this is a big deal in this case, though .gif is pretty much dead, unless you use an old browser on old tech, but then why would you be reading this story?

Look on the bright side, at least this isnt a Codec vs. Codec story, where the author uses jpgs for such color-limited screenshots.

Reply
RE: GIF by deathwombat, 721 days ago
In addition to being less ugly, PNG's higher compression would also make the file smaller (using less bandwidth), which I assume is what they were going for.

Reply
AMD's ghost product by DigitalFreak, 724 days ago
Three months or so since "launch", and you still can't get a server with AMD quad-core chips from any of the big 3 vendors (HP, Dell, IBM). AMD really screwed the pooch on this one.

Reply
Excellent article! by jones377, 724 days ago
Any chance you could use the same tools to profile desktop applications as well in the future?

Reply
Very Nice by AssBall, 724 days ago
Thanks, Johan.

This has been one of the clearer and better proofread articles I have read here lately. It was interesting, unbiased, and insightful. I am excited to see what you get into for your next project.

Reply
RE: Very Nice by Bluestealth, 724 days ago
I agree, it was a very well done article. I can't wait to see how Intel's processors preform on Hyper... errr... Common System Interface (next year?). I believe that I will be buying AMD until that happens though for any servers.

Reply
Comments Page 1 of 5

Free Forrester Risk Management Report
Demystifying Enterprise Risk Management. Download Free With Registration.
DOWNLOAD vWire Today - FREE TRIAL
Take Control of Your Virtual Infrastructure. Manage VI Data & Prevent Problems.
Report Unlicensed Business Software Use
Earn Up to $1 Million by Reporting Unlicensed Software Use. Fill Out Our Form!
Download Microsoft Visual Studio ® Team System
Streamline Dev processes, Reduce time to market. Try Microsoft Visual Studio Team System, FREE!
Supermicro Barebone Servers
We Carry Everything Supermicro. Low Price, Top Service, FREE Shipping, and more.




Latest news by
DailyTech

 November 20, 2009

Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank

 November 19, 2009

Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank
Blank




pipeboost
Copyright © 1997-2009 AnandTech, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms, Conditions and Privacy Information.
Click Here for Advertising Information