Crucial RealSSD C300 Firmware, Part IIIby Anand Lal Shimpi on May 6, 2010 7:19 PM EST
Poor Crucial. Although it started its C300 campaign on the right foot, posting some very impressive sequential read speeds thanks to 6Gbps SATA and ONFI 2.0 NAND, things haven't been so smooth lately.
First off, Crucial's timing was unfortunate as it was right around the time we started seeing SandForce make some noise. Secondly, while performance was good, my drive showed some performance and reliability issues within two weeks of receiving it. And third, the firmware update that was supposed to address the problems I had managed to brick some drives.
If you bought a C300 there was a chance that your drive would brick itself by just using it. If you used the firmware that fixed the aforementioned problem, then there was a chance the process would brick your drive.
Crucial just gave me an update on the situation and things appear to be looking up:
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
mdevlin - Sunday, May 9, 2010 - linkMust be lucky. I have four of the 256GB C300s with no problems at all. Using the four C300s in a pair of Addonics Dual Drive RAID enclosures. Limited by the eSATA performance through Expresscard34 on MacBook Pro, but otherwise no issues at all. Primarily using them with Final Cut Pro.
Xtrykr - Monday, May 10, 2010 - linkHi Anand, did Crucial send you any beta firmware updates to test? Or do you think we're going to be hooped for a while?
P.S. what is the real issue with C300 that is causing the degradation over time? Thanks!
Kevin the Tech - Monday, May 10, 2010 - linkCan you confirm whether the new firmware fixes the performance degradation and TRIM commands. These drives are looking mighty tempting if they can get those issues sorted out.
pengivy - Tuesday, May 11, 2010 - linkWhere is the firmware?? The link of C300 is gone??
I can't find it now...
d3vnul - Tuesday, May 18, 2010 - linkGuess it takes more time for the firmware to show up , i'm getting one C300 256GB in 2-3days (on shipping at the moment) , hopefully they will release the firmware this month so i can update my drive before using it
spudit88 - Thursday, May 20, 2010 - linkI posted on his previous C300 article. Note- I would not purchase one of these without the updated firmware. The one I bought last week died after only 1 day- Loading everything up...spend some time testing...was pretty happy- Came in this morning and the thing is toast.
Tried to update Firmware, etc. with no luck. They are replacing with an updated drive.
I'm shocked they are still selling these (direct no less) with such problems-
smithwd - Thursday, May 20, 2010 - linkFor what its worth - the new firmware is back out with a new and improved updater.
Here's a link: http://www.crucial.com/support/firmware.aspx
I will try it tomorrow and let you know how it works.
smithwd - Friday, May 21, 2010 - linkI followed the directions and the update worked for me with no problems.
NurFACE1 - Friday, May 21, 2010 - linkI followed the firmware update from crucial. I haven't had any problem with drive but decided to use firmware update release 002. No problem with latest firmware for me. I set bios to IDE = ATA place SSD on port 1 of sata II and disconnected remaining drives until flash completed. The performance has remain a positive experience for me.
turbodreams - Sunday, May 23, 2010 - linkThe new Firmware does indeed solve the TRIM issue, as it can be seen here:
First screenshot shows the drive after heavy Iometer load, last screenshot show the drive after a "quick format".
Note that neither sequential writes nor an extended idle period seem to trigger the garbage collection (second & third screenshot), so the GC seems much weaker than on Intel drives.