Doom3 Linux and Windows Battlegrounds
by Kristopher Kubicki on October 13, 2004 12:50 AM EST- Posted in
- Linux
Final Thoughts
The majority of our analysis revolved around image quality for this first look at Doom3 on Linux. NVIDIA's addition of 16X and 8X Anti-Aliasing to the 1.0-6111 driver was a welcomed feature. The practicality of running 16X or 8X AA during game play is about nil (as shown on the previous pages), but any Linux user should appreciate a feature that they have over a Windows user. Hopefully, the infrequent crashing issue with higher AA levels will be fixed in the next driver revision.The practicality of NVIDIA's Texture Sharpening is already somewhat contested; it only bumps the AF slider one bar (and without telling the user). For Linux, enabling Texture Sharpening seemed to provide no performance or image quality benefits.
Finally, to answer the question of which OS runs Doom3 faster - unfortunately, there really was not the type of contest that we had anticipated. Yes, Doom3 for Linux stays competitive with Doom3 for Windows, but in several instances, it falls more than 25% behind on NVIDIA graphics cards. If and when ATI cards start working for Doom3, we are likely to see even larger differences.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
36 Comments
View All Comments
jediknight - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
#15 - My bad to make such generalizations..but the fact that you can't even use an ATI card to play D3 doesn't bode well for Linux gaming...
jensend - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
#14- bunk. All you can take away from this review is that Windows "owns Linux for" D3 1.1 performance. You can't generalize this for game performance in general. Most games show a less than 5% difference.BTW, another article on the same topic with more detail is at http://www.linuxhardware.org/article.pl?sid=04/10/...
jediknight - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
I like the difference pictures.. although when you get up to 8x and 16x, they're probably unnecessary.But the thing to take away from this review is that Windows owns Linux for gaming performance.
icehot - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
Interesting article. Was it just me or are the difference maps just pure black? Also I dont think things like 16xAA are really needed, after 2x or 4x the differences between anything higher and the original image is negligable, and definately not noticeable when playing, maybe if you really take the time to admire the scenary, but who does that when fighting monsters??Lwood - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
According to an article over at LinuxHardware.org, the Linux build of Doom 3 is currently less optimized than the Windows build.Most notably SSE2 code is missing (but will be added later) and GCC does not optimize as good as VC.net.
Details here:
http://www.linuxhardware.org/article.pl?sid=04/10/...
I guess we can expect the gap to get smaller in later Doom 3 builds, but not to disappear entirely.
ViRGE - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
Kris, odd, I swear that I was only getting 2 graphs per page when I read the article. I don't know if Firefox is bugging out on me or what.reljam - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
Kris, please put Windows and Linux numbers on the same graph, you know that people will want to see how they stack up against each other.Not clear on why you wouldn't want to do that.
jensend - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
Neither NV nor id has much of a reason to optimize heavily for linux, and it's entirely unsurprising that the windows version performs better. Nevertheless, I expect that the gap will close considerably as the Doom 3 engine matures.Myrandex - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
The AA pictures won't work for me. When I click on them, I get a new window w/ the alert 'hold your mouse over the picture' and then the page doesn't load. When I hold my mouse over the original image, nothing happens. Also, the black pictures to the right of those are way to black to tell a thing about them. Interesting article though. I wonder if 16X AA would be playable in a lower resolution.Jason
Lwood - Wednesday, October 13, 2004 - link
That bit about the 16x AA you can enable in Linux is surely interesting. Maybe you can try this on a less performance-demanding game than Doom 3.I'd love to see UT 2004 and Enemy Territory benchmarks for this mode... :-)